Handcrafted since 1919

Our Flavors

Thirty-four flavors, every batch made in small runs — quality first, quantity second.

Handcrafted since 1919

Our Flavors

Every batch made in small runs, the way the original Petersen’s did it in Oak Park. Quality first — quantity second.

Amaretto Cherry

Amaretto ice cream loaded with cherries and chocolate flakes.
Apple Crisp

Cinnamon-apple ice cream layered with oatmeal crisps and topped with a brown butter swirl.
Bear Claw

Sweet dark chocolate ice cream swirled with caramel and loaded with whistle chocolate coated cashews.
Blue Moon

Traditional nutty and fruity flavored, bright blue ice cream.
Butter Pecan

Rich, buttery ice cream loaded with roasted pecan halves for the perfect balance of sweet and nutty flavor.
Carolina Peach

Bushels of sweet peach chunks dropped into creamy peach ice cream.
Carrot Cake

Cinnamon spice ice cream laced with cream cheese frosting and carrot cake slices.
Chocolate

Rich, creamy chocolate ice cream made with premium cocoa for a smooth and decadent flavor.
Cookie Dough

Chocolate chip cookie dough flavored ice cream, homestyle cookie dough and chocolate chip morsels.
Cool Mint Cookie

Mint ice cream with chocolate covered mint cookie balls, Andes mints and a chocolate cookie fudge swirl.
Dubai Chocolate

Creamy chocolate ice cream with swirls of rich, pistachio butter and crispy, chocolate crunchies.
Eskimo Kisses

Cool, coconut ice cream kissed with chocolate truffles and warmed by a thick blanket of fudge.
Graham Canyon

Graham cracker-flavored ice cream, swirled with graham cracker ripples and studded with chocolate-covered honeycomb toffee pieces.
Jacked up Tennessee Toffee

Toffee ice cream laced with smooth, whiskey sweet sauce and garnished with broken heath bars.
Lemon Bar Cheesecake

Lemon bar ice cream filled with cheesecake chunks and graham cracker crust swirl.
Mackinac Fudge Island

Creamy vanilla ice cream swirled with rich butter fudge and packed with generous chunks of chewy fudge.
Majestic Milky Way

Chocolate malt flakes blended with a caramel fudge ribbon in milk chocolate ice cream.
Marion Blackberry

Fruity, blackberry ice cream layered with blackberry sauce.
Michigan Pot Hole

Thick, black tar fudge in chocolate ice cream with chunks of chocolate asphalt.
Nana’s Banana Puddin

Banana pudding ice cream swirled with marshmallow creme and vanilla cookies.
O O Oreo

Oreo cheesecake ice cream with crushed oreo cookies swirled in.
Peanut Butter Cup

Chocolate ice cream with a rich peanut butter ripple and peanut butter cups.
Pistachio Almond

Pistachio flavored ice cream with crisp, toasted almonds.
Puppy Chow

Peanut butter ice cream blended with a decadent chocolate swirl and generous chunks of crunchy Puppy Chow pieces.
Raspberry Chip Cheesecake

Creamy ice cream with a raspberry swirl and loaded with chocolate chip flakes.
Raspberry Rendezvous

Black raspberry ice cream with thick fudge and dark chocolate raspberry filled candies.
Rush Hour

Coffee ice cream with creamy, caramel swirl and chocolate coffee candy chips.
Sea Turtle

Sea salt caramel ice cream and salty caramel swirl with chocolate caramel turtles.
Sherbet Orange

Cool crisp orange taste.
Strawberry

Strawberry ice cream with diced strawberries.
Strawberry Cheesecake

Cheesecake ice cream with strawberry ripple and chunks of traditional cheesecake.
Superman

Fluorescent lemon yellow with strawberry red and bubble gum blue ice cream.
Ultimate Peanut Butter Brownie

Creamy PB ice cream packed with fudgy brownies and drizzled with caramel.
Vanilla

Rich, creamy vanilla ice cream made with pure vanilla for a timeless, classic flavor.
No flavors in that category yet.